georgeealien's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sonic's Sandwich]

yeah

Gray responds:

Yeah

[Never Forget - 9/11 Animation]

This is confusing, this feels like it's making fun of 9/11, but then you plaster a bunch of memorials to the people that died. It's hard to tell if this was a joke or not.

If it wasn't, then it's pretty distasteful. Especially self inserting yourself into a real-life tragedy, that's a bit fucked up ngl.

EpicJohn11 responds:

Well, I wasn't intending for it to seem as if I was making fun of it. So to answer that, I wasn't making fun of it.

To avoid future viewers from being confused, I'll include an addition to the description.

I also apologize for it being distasteful. I was trying to show others that were for whatever reason not aware of 9/11, how people experienced the tragedy and what happened. I understand that it was kinda fucked up, and I also apologize for that. My animations tend to be very dark, but I don't like making them too dark. To clarify, there were a lot of more fucked up and disturbing content on this website related to 9/11. Such as, "9/11 Simulator" or whatever it was called.

[WHEN BUNGEE JUMPING GOES WRONG]

This was surprisingly good, the animation was stellar given its simplicity. I like that you actually strive to add interesting angles during the action.

I feel like this worked fine without the ending joke, though. The imagery of a dude bungee jumping with his own intestines was good enough because it was a classic case of a character getting their comeuppance. It gets a bit muddled now that two randies were killed alongside him.

10outof10animations responds:

Hey there, I'm really happy that you enjoy the animation, thank you very much for your positive rating, I really appreciate it :D

Yeah, you're definitely right about the ending joke, it is kinda unnecessary and out of place, but I decided to keep it because I thought it to be really funny and it also shows that revenge, no matter how deserved it may seem, always has messy side-effects (just kidding, I only kept it because I found it funny :D)

[Eddsworld - Dubstep Sunglasses reanimated]

I like how you made it super expressive compared to the original, pretty ace :)

fezbet responds:

Thanks!

[Androids Aren't Funky Fresh]

Pretty fucking good, lip syncing is so damn nice

[I'm At Soup!!!!]

Really not that good tbh, I've seen a few animations that use this audio and they all did something fun and unique with the visuals. This just has 2 characters standing around, barely emoting. Doesn't help that the artwork is really lacking. A lot of work needs to be done on the character animation and expression.

JoesTo0ns responds:

I completely understand, and thanks for the constructive criticism,

Also I am new to animating so thats probably why.

[Home Alone Simplified]

I don't wanna discredit the hard work that clearly went into this, because the animation is really good, but it seems way too similar to casvdp's ultimate recap series. Not just in concept, either; some of the jokes feel very reminiscent of his style.

Fitzpresident responds:

I love Cas's cartoons, and they're definitely an inspiration (along with TerminalMontage's Something About series and a number of other "in a nutshell" cartoons over the last decade and a half), but it's not my intention to rip off his style. Maybe once I've made some more they'll evolve into something a bit more distinct :)

[What the HELL is Disney? (The WORST Company Ever)]

This feels like you didn't write a script and you just kind of made it up as you went along. That, or you wrote a script and it's just incredibly repetitive. Bring up your point, make the point and move on. You ramble too much. It doesn't help that the topic you chose is too broad and doesn't add anything new to the table.

Also, the animated character looks really bad.
This is trying to be like a lot of things and it doesn't really succeed at any of them.

AndriuxDev responds:

Obviously, I made a script that is available on my Patreon. Also, there are far more crimes Disney made on its timeline; at some point, Disney was sued by COPPA because of spying on kids all around the city thanks to some microchips which are capable of tracking every kid's location as if it was the Disney's own version of the FBI.